Open Chain Exercises
/When it comes to training effectively, especially for athletes or those recovering from injury, the types of exercises you choose can significantly impact your performance and recovery. One topic that frequently comes up is the use of open-chain exercises. As a coach, I’ve seen both the benefits and drawbacks of these exercises, and it’s crucial to understand when and how they should be used. Let’s dive into what open-chain exercises are, how they compare to closed-chain movements, and whether they have a place in your training routine.
Enhance your strength, power, and endurance with our specialized Kettlebell Workout Programs for Swimmers. Designed by Coach Dan Daly, CSCS, these programs blend functional exercises with effective kettlebell movements tailored to elevate your performance in the water and beyond. Whether you’re looking to build a solid foundation or develop explosive athleticism, we have the perfect plan for you
What is an Open Chain Exercise?
To start, let’s define the term: What are open chain exercises? Movements where the distal end (hand or foot) is free to move and not fixed or stationary. These exercises typically involve single-joint movement and are less stable, as the extremity moves freely in space. In simpler terms, the moving limb (like your leg or arm) is free to move in space, and there is no anchor point restricting its motion. Examples of open-chain exercises include leg extensions, lat pull downs, and bicep curls. In these movements, the limb is typically working against a load without any stability from the ground or another fixed surface.
What is a Closed Chain Exercise?
Let’s define the term: What are closed chain exercises? These are movements where the distal end (hand or foot) is fixed or stationary, often in contact with a solid surface like the ground or a bar. These exercises typically involve multiple joints and require the body to move around the fixed extremity, creating a stable and functional movement pattern. In simpler terms, the hand or foot remains anchored, and the rest of the body adjusts and moves. Examples of closed-chain exercises include squats, push-ups, and pull-ups. In these movements, the fixed limb provides stability and engages multiple muscles and joints, making them excellent for building functional strength and joint stability.
Open Chain vs. Closed Chain Exercises
When comparing open kinetic chain exercises to closed chain exercises, the distinction lies in whether the hands or feet are fixed. In a closed chain movement, like squats or lunges, your feet are planted on the ground, which provides stability and engages more muscles. Closed-chain vs. open-chain exercise discussions often highlight the superior functional benefits of closed-chain exercises, especially for athletes.
Closed chain movements are arguably more functional because they simulate real-life activities, improve joint stability, and activate multiple muscle groups. On the other hand, open chain movements isolate specific muscles, which can be beneficial in certain rehabilitation scenarios but often lack the comprehensive benefits of multi-joint, functional movements.
open chain exercise examples
Examples of Open Chain Exercises
To give you a clearer picture, here are some common open-chain exercise examples:
Leg Extensions: An open chain quad exercise that targets the quadriceps while the lower leg moves freely.
Seated Hamstring Curls: An open chain hamstring exercise that isolates the hamstrings with limited engagement of stabilizing muscles.
Bicep Curls: The classic arm workout that isolates the biceps without requiring balance or additional core stabilization.
These exercises are often found in gyms and are popular because they target specific muscle groups. However, they have limitations, especially if your goal is functional strength and athletic performance.
Coach Dan Daly, CSCS, demonstrates proper form and power-building techniques on the leg press.
The Limitations of Open Chain Movements
Now, you might be wondering, what is an open chain exercise good for if it comes with so many limitations? Open-chain exercises have specific uses, primarily in rehabilitation and targeted muscle training. For example, after a knee injury, performing leg extensions can help rebuild quad strength without bearing weight. However, the drawbacks often outweigh the benefits for healthy individuals and athletes.
Increased Joint Stress: Open chain leg exercises can place undue stress on the joints, especially when performed with heavy weights. The lack of ground stability means that joints, like the knees and hips, are more susceptible to strain.
Limited Functional Transfer: Since open chain movements do not mimic real-life or athletic activities, they often don’t translate well to improved sports performance or daily function. Functional strength comes from closed chain, weight-bearing movements that engage multiple muscle groups and joints.
Reduced Proprioceptive Feedback: Open chain exercises eliminate the vital sensory input from having your feet in contact with the ground. This feedback is essential for developing balance, stability, and body awareness.
The Case for Functional Training
As the science behind strength training evolves, there is a clear shift toward functional, multi-joint exercises. These movements mimic how our bodies move in real life, engaging multiple muscle groups and improving overall stability and coordination. Exercises like squats, lunges, deadlifts, and pull-ups not only activate more muscles but also enhance your core strength, balance, and calorie burn.
So, where do open-chain exercises fit into the picture? They can be useful in specific situations. For example, a client recovering from plantar fasciitis or someone dealing with lower limb injuries might need to avoid weight-bearing movements temporarily. In these cases, open-chain quad exercises like seated leg extensions can play a crucial role in maintaining muscle strength while protecting the injured area.
However, for most athletes and fitness enthusiasts, machines that isolate muscles—like the leg extension or inner and outer thigh machines—should be used sparingly. They don’t replicate the multi-muscle engagement required in sports or functional activities.
Why Functional Movements Are Superior
Functional, closed-chain movements are not only more effective for athletic training but also safer for the joints. Take, for example, a squat: this exercise engages the quads, hamstrings, glutes, and core, all while improving balance and joint stability. Contrast that with a leg extension, where only the quads are engaged, and the knees take on significant stress.
Open-chain exercises were popularized during the bodybuilding boom of the 1970s. Back then, the focus was on isolating muscles for aesthetics rather than functional strength. However, research has shown that multi-joint exercises burn more calories, improve overall athleticism, and reduce the risk of injury.
Incorporating Open Chain Exercises Wisely
So, should you avoid open-chain exercises entirely? Not necessarily. The key is understanding when and how to incorporate them into your routine. Here are some guidelines:
Use for Rehabilitation: If you’re coming back from an injury, open-chain exercises can be a valuable tool for regaining strength without bearing weight.
Supplementary Training: Use open chain movements to target specific muscle groups after your primary, functional lifts. For instance, after a heavy leg day, you might add some light leg extensions to fully fatigue the quads.
Avoid Heavy Weights: To minimize joint stress, avoid using heavy loads for open-chain exercises. Focus instead on controlled movements with a moderate weight.
In the debate of closed chain vs. open chain exercise, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Open chain movements have their place, particularly in rehabilitation or as supplementary exercises. However, for functional strength, joint health, and overall athletic performance, closed-chain exercises reign supreme. As a coach, I prioritize training that translates to real-world strength and endurance, and I encourage my clients to focus on movements that make them more resilient athletes.
By understanding the role and limitations of open-chain exercises, you can create a training plan that keeps you strong, healthy, and ready to perform.
Boost your strength, endurance, and mobility with our expertly designed dryland training programs. Perfect for swimmers and athletes aiming to maximize performance both in and out of the water.